Makeup Top Sellers
🏆 Best Seller
⭐ MAG Pick
❤️ Customer Favorite
🎁 Gift Favorite
Curated with Purpose
At My American Goods®, every collection is thoughtfully selected to showcase quality products from American makers, artisans, and small businesses. We're proud to connect customers with brands that still believe in craftsmanship, authenticity, and making things the right way.
Shop All Makeup
200 products
-
Papabear Tallow Lip Balm - (5 Pack)Vendor:Papabear Tallow Lip Balm - (5 Pack)PapaBear Naturals- Regular price
-
$22.95 - Regular price
-
- Sale price
-
$22.95
-
*New* VanMan's Beeswax Lip BalmVendor:*New* VanMan's Beeswax Lip BalmVanMan- Regular price
-
$5.00 $21.00 - Regular price
-
$5.00 - Sale price
-
$5.00 $21.00
-
Organic Lash & Brow Serum with cold pressed castor oil and pearl powderVendor:Organic Lash & Brow Serum with cold pressed castor oil and pearl powderRoots And Leaves- Regular price
-
$21.99 - Regular price
-
- Sale price
-
$21.99
-
Dakota Tallow Lip Balm - 3 PackVendor:Dakota Tallow Lip Balm - 3 PackDakota Tallow- Regular price
-
$10.50 - Regular price
-
- Sale price
-
$10.50
-
Lady May Tallow Lip Balm | All Natural Beef Tallow Lip BalmVendor:Lady May Tallow Lip Balm | All Natural Beef Tallow Lip BalmLady May Tallow- Regular price
-
$10.00 - Regular price
-
$0.00 - Sale price
-
$10.00
-
Mascara | lash-growth + curlVendor:Mascara | lash-growth + curlTaylor Made Organics- Regular price
-
$21.00 - Regular price
-
- Sale price
-
$21.00
-
Sheep Tallow Lip BalmVendor:Sheep Tallow Lip BalmAnnwn- Regular price
-
From
$10.00 - Regular price
-
$30.00 - Sale price
-
From
$10.00
-
Summer Dew | Aloe Vera Liquid FoundationVendor:Summer Dew | Aloe Vera Liquid Foundationurban farm collection- Regular price
-
$2.00 $29.00 - Regular price
-
- Sale price
-
$2.00 $29.00
-
Lip Balms - (Essential Oils)Vendor:Lip Balms - (Essential Oils)Creme de la Crop- Regular price
-
$4.85 - Regular price
-
- Sale price
-
$4.85
-
Natural Liquid FoundationVendor:Natural Liquid FoundationCandid Naturals- Regular price
-
$18.99 $37.99 - Regular price
-
- Sale price
-
$18.99 $37.99
-
Fat Stick, Lavender + Peppermint, 0.5 OzVendor:Fat Stick, Lavender + Peppermint, 0.5 OzFATCO Skincare Products- Regular price
-
$10.00 - Regular price
-
- Sale price
-
$10.00
-
Fat Stick, Orange + Vanilla, 0.5 OzVendor:Fat Stick, Orange + Vanilla, 0.5 OzFATCO Skincare Products- Regular price
-
$10.00 - Regular price
-
- Sale price
-
$10.00
-
Brow Gel | tint and tameVendor:Brow Gel | tint and tameTaylor Made Organics- Regular price
-
$21.00 $24.00 - Regular price
-
- Sale price
-
$21.00 $24.00
-
Beet Lip StickVendor:Beet Lip Stickplant makeup- Regular price
-
$14.00 $22.00 - Regular price
-
$0.00 - Sale price
-
$14.00 $22.00
-
Loose Mineral FoundationVendor:Loose Mineral FoundationTaylor Made Organics- Regular price
-
$1.00 $28.00 - Regular price
-
- Sale price
-
$1.00 $28.00
-
Rose Tallow Lip Balm (tinted)Vendor:Rose Tallow Lip Balm (tinted)My Neighbor’s- Regular price
-
$22.00 - Regular price
-
- Sale price
-
$22.00
-
Shea Butter & Almond Lip BalmVendor:Shea Butter & Almond Lip BalmHeliotrope SF- Regular price
-
$9.00 $29.00 - Regular price
-
$9.00 - Sale price
-
$9.00 $29.00
-
Brow Powder | organic brow enhancerVendor:Brow Powder | organic brow enhancerTaylor Made Organics- Regular price
-
$26.00 - Regular price
-
- Sale price
-
$26.00
-
BioGlow Tinted Moisturizer with TallowVendor:BioGlow Tinted Moisturizer with TallowGinger Lily Tallow- Regular price
-
$35.00 - Regular price
-
- Sale price
-
$35.00
